Classify features by satisfaction impact. Separate basics, performance drivers, delighters, low-value work, and reverse effects.
Goal
Help users decide feature priority. Classify each feature by customer satisfaction impact.
Categories
- Must-be: expected baseline. Missing causes dissatisfaction. Presence prevents complaints.
- One-dimensional: more or better increases satisfaction; less or worse decreases satisfaction.
- Attractive: unexpected delight. Presence increases satisfaction. Absence does not hurt.
- Indifferent: little satisfaction impact either way.
- Reverse: more of the feature reduces satisfaction for some users.
- Questionable: contradictory response. Exclude or inspect.
Rules
- Use behavior, support tickets, churn reasons, sales objections, interviews, or survey data.
- Treat stakeholder guesses as hypotheses.
- Split segments when categories conflict.
- Re-check old classifications; delighters can become basics.
- Do not treat delighters as a substitute for broken must-haves.
- Do not overbuild must-haves unless they support positioning.
- Keep survey design optional. Most users need priority advice first.
Flow
- Clarify user segment and product context.
- Rewrite feature ideas as user-visible outcomes.
- Classify each feature.
- Pick action from category.
- Rank within each action group by evidence strength and strategic fit.
- Name unknowns and fastest validation.
Actions
- Must-be: protect baseline.
- One-dimensional: improve when strategic.
- Attractive: add selectively for differentiation.
- Indifferent: cut, defer, or de-scope.
- Reverse: remove, segment, or make optional.
- Questionable: inspect before deciding.
Optional Validation
Use lightweight research when evidence is weak:
- Ask what users expect as baseline.
- Ask what absence would block, annoy, or not matter.
- Ask what presence would delight, help, or feel like clutter.
Resources
references/sources.md: load only for formal Kano surveys, answer mapping, satisfaction coefficients, source citations, or deeper method checks.
Output
## Kano Analysis
Segment:
Context:
## Features
- [Feature]
- Category: [category]
- Evidence: [signal]
- Confidence: [low / medium / high]
- Action: [action]
## Priority
- Protect:
- Improve:
- Add:
- Cut or defer:
- Segment conflicts:
## Next Validation
- Unknowns:
- Fastest check:
- Re-check date: